Is My Website Costing Me Customers? Here’s How to Tell

A black circle with a pattern of nine white squares arranged in a staircase or ascending bar chart shape, with a trademark “TM” symbol to the upper right.

RCD Geeks

Published on May 13, 2025
White clock icon with hour and minute hands inside a circular outline on a dark gray background, suggesting the concept of time or scheduling.

Read Time

3 min read

Your website is like your business’s digital storefront. If it’s outdated, confusing, or doesn’t clearly explain what you do, you might be losing potential customers without even realizing it. 

Not sure if your business website is working for you—or against you? Here’s what to look for.

Do Visitors Know They’re in the Right Place?

When someone lands on your website, they should instantly know they’ve found what they’re looking for. If they feel unsure or confused, they’re likely to leave and look elsewhere.

  • Speak Your Customer’s Language – Avoid complicated industry jargon. Your website should feel like a natural conversation with your ideal customer.
  • Keep Your Branding Consistent – If your website, social media and business cards all look different, people might not recognize your brand. A consistent brand builds trust and credibility.
  • Make Your Location Obvious – If you’re a local business, show it! Include your phone number, address and real photos of your area so customers know you serve them.

Can Customers Easily Take the Next Step?

If someone is interested in your services, what’s the next step? Your website should make it easy for them to contact you or book an appointment.

  • Highlight Your Call-to-Action (CTA) – A CTA is the step you want customers to take, like “Call Us Now” or “Book a Consultation.” It should be clear and easy to find.
  • Remove Barriers – If visitors have to dig through multiple pages to find your contact info, they might give up. Keep it simple and obvious.

Does Your Business Website Look Trustworthy?

First impressions matter. A poorly designed website can make potential customers question whether your business is legitimate.

  • Keep It Updated – If your website looks like it hasn’t changed in years, potential customers may assume your business is outdated too.
  • Avoid a Cluttered Look – If you’ve made random updates over time, your site might feel messy. A clean, professional design makes a big difference.
  • Make Navigation Simple – A confusing menu or broken links can frustrate visitors and drive them away.

Are You Using Real, High-Quality Photos?

People connect with real people. Great images of your team, your office and happy customers help build trust.

  • Use Real Photos When Possible – Stock images are fine in some cases, but real photos help customers feel more connected to your brand.
  • Prioritize Relatable Images – If budget is a concern, mix real and high-quality stock photos. Avoid staged or overly generic images.

Does Your Website Feel Authentic?

Customers can tell when something feels off. AI-generated content might be efficient, but if it sounds robotic, people will notice.

  • Write Like a Human – Your website should sound like your brand, not a machine. Customers want to connect with real people.
  • Be Genuine – Your website should reflect your personality, values and how you do business.

Do You Have Social Proof?

People trust other people’s experiences. Customer reviews and testimonials can make a big impact on whether someone decides to work with you.

  • Showcase Real Customer Reviews – Highlight testimonials from happy customers to build credibility.
  • Be Consistent Across Platforms – If your website says you’re great, but your Google reviews tell a different story, people will notice.
  • Display Recognizable Partners – If you’ve worked with well-known businesses, showcase their logos to reinforce trust.

Is Your Website Easy to Skim?

Not everyone reads websites the same way. Some want detailed information, while others just need a quick answer. Your site should cater to both.

  • Use Headings and Bullet Points – This helps break up large blocks of text so visitors can find what they need quickly.
  • Put Key Info Front and Center – Your services, location and contact info shouldn’t be buried at the bottom of the page.
  • Balance Simplicity with Depth – Provide enough detail for those who want to research, but keep it organized for those who prefer to skim.

Is Your Website Helping or Hurting Your Business?

Your website should be working for you—not driving customers away. If you’re unsure whether your site is doing its job, it might be time for a refresh.

At Rock City Digital, we help businesses in Central and Northwest Arkansas create websites that attract and convert customers. Contact us today and let’s make your website work for you!

Ready for us to audit your site and help improve your rankings?

We’ll take an honest look at where you are, where you want to go, and how to get you there—no gimmicks, just growth.

Related Resources

Sample Blog Post 4

Sample Blog Post 4

Lorem ipsum odor amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Ornare ex rhoncus ridiculus natoque; lacinia condimentum sollicitudin. Platea nostra magnis ridiculus taciti scelerisque dignissim. Sagittis mollis aptent consequat maecenas maximus aptent montes massa inceptos....